Old Site


Bookninja 2.0:



.

Hearsay:

September 10, 2007

Writing when you can’t read

I’ve been following this story, about Canadian crime writer Howard Engel’s stroke and subsequent loss of the ability to read, for some time because my first poetic mentor is the guy who helped Engel write his memoir (largely by reading back what had been written). Imagine spending your entire life as a writer and then having a stroke that leaves you with the ability to write, but not the ability to read, even what you’ve just written. Who ever heard of such a thing. This gives me the same weeping sympathy and fear as reading about “locked-in syndrome”. I almost shudder at the thought.

Of all the ways to learn that your brain has suffered an “insult,” as medical professionals like to call the effects of strokes, one of the oddest is to get up in the morning and discover your Toronto newspaper seemingly printed in a mix of Serbo-Croatian and Korean. When 70-year-old Howard Engel came back inside with his Globe and Mail that hot July day in 2001 and found he couldn’t read his own books either, the bestselling mystery novelist headed for the hospital. Tests confirmed Engel’s own assumption: stroke, left side, rear. His memory was shot — still is, for that matter, especially for names — and he had lost a quarter of his vision, on the upper right side. But the essence of the diagnosis was a rare and almost incomprehensible condition: alexia sine agraphia. The elegant combination of Greek and Latin words meant that while Engel could still write, he could no longer read.

Such a triumph that he’s back at it.  The mind is a mysterious and fucked-up thing. It’s like a lava lamp of possible injury. I just finished a great book called Into the Silent Land by Paul Brok, in which Engel’s ailment could have been used for any variety of Brok’s eloquent riffing on identity. It’s a testament to the machinery of the brain, but also the force of will, that Engel’s writing at all.

Share the 'Ninja with your 2.0 friends:
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • StumbleUpon
  • Reddit
  • del.icio.us
  • LinkedIn
  • Digg
  • RSS
  • Print
  • email

3 comments on “Writing when you can’t read”

  1. Niteowl says:

    I can think of few things — except the ‘locked in’ syndrome and perhaps death — worse than that.

  2. ZW says:

    “It’s a testament to the machinery of the brain, but also the force of will, that Engel’s writing at all.”

    G, this is a false dualism; the force of will is a product of the “machinery of the brain.” I know this seems nitpicky, but this kind of Cartesian fallacy is responsible for an awful lot of misapprehensions about brain/body and soul/mind. There’s not so much a “ghost in the machine” as a machine that makes ghosts. Engel’s affliction and many other forms of verbal agnosia caused by brain damage are fascination evidence for just how inseparable mind and brain really are and how much language is an integral part of the human body, not simply a created technology.

  3. ZW says:

    Sorry, “fascinating” not “fascination.” I need some sleep.

Discuss

Latest comments:
George on
News catchup
Monica on
News catchup
Andrew S on
News catchup
Shelley on
On the dangers of writing about the past
Steven W. Beattie on
Get out there, nerds!
Sean Dixon on
Facebook claims it owns the word "book"
Sean Dixon on
Under-rated Canadian writers
Franklin Carter on
Under-rated Canadian writers
Steven Jensen on
Facebook claims it owns the word "book"
Rob Payne on
Under-rated Canadian writers
Rob Payne on
Under-rated Canadian writers
Brian Busby on
Under-rated Canadian writers
Blake on
Under-rated Canadian writers
Aaron on
Under-rated Canadian writers
Aaron on
Under-rated Canadian writers
Bart King on
How to be a good loser
A.G. Pasquella on
Facebook claims it owns the word "book"
Fred on
Facebook claims it owns the word "book"
Zachariah Wells on
Under-rated Canadian writers
Steven W. Beattie on
Under-rated Canadian writers


Search blog:
Archives:
Old site archive:

January 2006
December 2005
November 2005
October 2005
September 2005
August 2005
July 2005
June 2005
May 2005
April 2005
March 2005
February 2005
January 2005
December 2004
November 2004
October 2004
September 2004
August 2004
July 2004
June 2004
May 2004
April 2004
March 2004
February 2004
January 2004
December 2003
November 2003
October 2003
September 2003
August 2003

Feeds: