Old Site


Bookninja 2.0:



.

Hearsay:

January 24, 2007

Great books with half the wit…

I shudder. Self-proclaimed bookninja fan Kerry delurks to tip this tidbit of disturbing news (fourth item) about a publisher who will be (trash) compacting the classics:

Despite the trend for new-look classics lists, no publisher has dared to meddle with the texts – until now. Weidenfeld & Nicolson is to launch a list of edited literary classics, called Compact Editions. It claims that market research shows many readers are put off by the “elitist” image of classics and by their daunting length and small print. So the Compact Editions – slogan “Great Books in Half the Time” – have been “sympathetically edited” down to fewer than 400 pages each. Weidenfeld insists that the novels retain the core plot, characters and historical background. The first six titles – Anna Karenina, Vanity Fair, David Copperfield, The Mill on the Floss, Moby-Dick and Wives and Daughters – are to be released in May and will doubtless be snapped up by students eager to cut down their reading time.

Author Jenny Ditski comments on her blog:

Who are these people who want to read scapelled classics?  They are very, very busy, but they’re just as entitled to feel cultured as anyone.  For some reason (a hangover from their grandparents’ education perhaps) they want to be able to say that they’ve read the classics, but they don’t want actually to read them.  A novel’s just a story, isn’t it?  Just the gist, please, I’m busy, very, very busy.  It’s odd, this: a long book of say 800 pages is the same as two gutted books of 400 pages each.  So they’re in a hurry to get as many titles under their belts as possible, and sod the structure, subplots and descriptive stuff.  Leave out the complexity.  This  creates a new definition of well read.  She read not wisely but too much.

Share the 'Ninja with your 2.0 friends:
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • StumbleUpon
  • Reddit
  • del.icio.us
  • LinkedIn
  • Digg
  • RSS
  • Print
  • email

7 comments on “Great books with half the wit…”

  1. peter says:

    This is old news, at least where childrens’ books are concerned. My father read endless classics that way, although he didn’t realise it until much later. If I recall, his abrdiged version of Martin Chuzzlewit only contained the US trip, for example. But he did develop a great love of Dickens. I don’t know but either those were the editions his school bought, or his parents, no doubt a way to buy a lot of books cheaply.

  2. George says:

    But there’s some difference in making books accessible to children and making them facile for adults. For instance, I introduced Boy Ninja to Milne’s Winnie-the-Pooh through Stephen Krensky’s early reader adaptations that made use of the Earnest Shepard “decorations”. It cuts much of the metanarrative and banter in the original stories, but kept enough plot to keep him interested. Later, we switched, almost seamlessly to the unabridged stories. We still read them regularly, particularly the Woozle hunt, in part because he wasn’t turned off by the more plodding parts when he was too young to get them.

    The question is, do we really need to do this for adults? And if we do, what does that say about the direction we’re headed in?

  3. Franklin Carter says:

    More than a hundred years ago, Mark Twain said that a classic is a book that everyone wants to have read but no one wants to read. He understood: people want to appear cultured without making any effort.

  4. susan says:

    I think these abridged novels are only justified in ESL courses or for very particular circumstances. When I taught at the Lycee Francais de Toronto I had my grade 5 English class put on a sixty minute Macbeth which was, for most of them, their first experience of Shakespeare and their first time acting. We analyzed the text (all Shakespeare, no additions, just deletions) and whenever we got into an interesting bit reverted to the original unabridged text to explore it in detail.

    But again, these were 10 year olds, and for many of the English was a second language. These abridged classics for adults remind me of a line in The Importance of Being Earnest about letting our servants do our living for us….

  5. Frankie the C says:

    If adults really want to appear literate at cocktail parties without spending long hours poring over the unexpurgated editions of Vanity Fair or War and Peace, they should just read Coles Notes.

  6. Jenny the C says:

    Want somthing ultra-compacted?
    Try Book-a-Minute Classics
    http://www.rinkworks.com/bookaminute/classics.shtml

  7. Gary Kemble says:

    Articulate asked its readers to summarise a classic in 10 words or less…

    Taming of the Shrew (abridged by Alex)

    Katherina: “Grrrrr”
    Petruchio: “Down Girl!”
    Katherina: “Purrrr”

    Want more? Go to: http://www.abc.net.au/news/arts/articulate/200701/s1835855.htm

Discuss

Latest comments:
B. Glen Rotchin on
Radio Noon -- words and phrases I hate
Dave on
Radio Noon -- words and phrases I hate
Dave on
Radio Noon -- words and phrases I hate
Brian Palmu on
Radio Noon -- words and phrases I hate
Peter on
Radio Noon -- words and phrases I hate
Berk Reynolds on
Radio Noon -- words and phrases I hate
The Storialist on
Radio Noon -- words and phrases I hate
Michael on
Radio Noon -- words and phrases I hate
fred on
Radio Noon -- words and phrases I hate
Terry Murray on
Radio Noon -- words and phrases I hate
Terry Murray on
Radio Noon -- words and phrases I hate
rr on
Radio Noon -- words and phrases I hate
Colleen on
Radio Noon -- words and phrases I hate
Teaching Poetry on
RIP: PK Page
Michael J on
Radio Noon -- words and phrases I hate
Brian on
Radio Noon -- words and phrases I hate
George on
Bill Watterson interview
Paul on
Bill Watterson interview
Art Norris on
Friggin snowday
zsuzsi on
Friggin snowday


Search blog:
Archives:
Old site archive:

January 2006
December 2005
November 2005
October 2005
September 2005
August 2005
July 2005
June 2005
May 2005
April 2005
March 2005
February 2005
January 2005
December 2004
November 2004
October 2004
September 2004
August 2004
July 2004
June 2004
May 2004
April 2004
March 2004
February 2004
January 2004
December 2003
November 2003
October 2003
September 2003
August 2003

Feeds: